Jennifer Coolidge Once Pretended to Be a Twin to Date 2 Men, and All We Can Say Is Legend

Jennifer Coolidge isn’t just the actress behind iconic characters like Legally Blonde’s Paulette, Stifler’s mom from American Pie, and A Cinderella Story’s Fiona, she’s iconic in her own right (the memes and impressions speak for themselves, after all). During her Jan. 29 appearance on The Kelly Clarkson Show, Jennifer discussed some legendary vacation behavior from a previous trip to Hawaii.
“When you come on vacation and you’re alone, you can kind of create anything you want,” she told the host. “I ended up meeting these two guys that were best friends. I liked them both, so I told them I had an identical twin and I dated both guys for two weeks.” Kelly immediately responded with, “That seems exhausting.” When asked whether he’d fall for the ruse, fellow guest Peter Krause responded with a straight face, “I’d have to find out which twin I like best, so at least twice.” You can hear Jennifer’s full story in the interview above.